s: [ 1 ] 2 All Go Down. Author Topic: Gospel of Barnabas Read times.
Very old book, maybe a gospel, found in turkey
Mohamed Saif Hero Member. Assalamun Alaikum I was recently doing some research on the Gospel of Barnabas. Most of the sources online say that it is a 16th century fraud done by some random Muslim.
Is this true or can somebody in this forum refute this? Thank you Mohamed Saif. AMuslimDude Hero Member.
No it isnt,since the Gospel of Barnabas was carbon dated,and text dated back to years ago,before the Prophet,and the language in it is not arabic therefore,it isnt false but a very very authentic scripture of the ebionites,The christians do anything to protect their faith so yeaah. Asalam ul laykum brothers, the discovery was of 16th century or so.
However, the work os translated to italian then translated to engliah, arabic and urdu, far as i know.
Gospel of barnabas
The people qho reject this doscovery try to use many techniques to disprove it's legitmacy, i admit some of the issue to sound as though that do not correspond with quran. However when looked at with "microscopic lens" you can see it very well corresponds with the quran.
Assalamun Alaikum Do you have any article that proves it is years old? If so could you please provide the links.
Affirming the historical existence of the gospel of barnabas
Asalam ul laykum brothers. I found a web where a brother named Adeel, refuted the answering-islam team's claims.
Dawud Hero Member. Idris Hero Member.
As-Salam aleikum wa rahmatullahi wa baraketuh, to be honest, the Gospel of Barnabas is incorrect when it comes to 2nd temple customs and geography. Although the Latin text could be a revision of some older document, possibly of that one mentioned in Decretum Gelasianum ca. What makes the Gospel of Barnabas also problematic — this time comparing it to the Quran - is the statement of Jesus pbuh in which he denies to be the Messiah!
Is there anyone besides Jesus pbuh in Islam's teaching who is recognized as the Messiah or anointed?? No doubt, the Gospel of Barnabas contains many truths, e. It is interesting that the Church of Rome has officially rejected this Gospel before the appearance of Prophet Mohammed pbuh.
Since Constantine chose to make Jesus pbuh as a final Saviour to all of humanity - a decision of Nicene Council in A. It is worthy to notice here that Codex Sinaiticus - i. In other words, we do not have any complete Gospel from the Pre-Nicene Church, and this is caused perhaps partly by the mass burning campaign of Christian books initiated through the orders of Roman Emperors like Severus, Decius, and Valerian.
It cannot be said that the Gospel of Barnabas which we have today is wholly authentic, since it contains some serious misconceptions, but it cannot be said also that it is entirely a forgery, since it tells many things which the Quran confirms, and Allah knows best! Syedsamad Hero Member.
Year old bible confirms that jesus christ was not crucified
I think it is somewhat hagiographical First, gospel of barnbas is not a book of God, it is barnabas memories written down in a book. So if a person write stuff from the memory, of course he will make mistakes, so those mistakes in barnabas gospel is proof that it is not forgery but actually proof that it is not forgery, beacuse if someone claim it was muslims who wrote it, then muslims cant lie, that is terrible sin, second if they wanted to match with islam they would not do such obvious errors.
So errors could arrive when person try to remember what he experienced long ago, and then start to write, and it is in human nature to make errors. And write in a similar manner that which has befallen Judas, in order that the faithful may be undeceived, and every one may believe the truth.
So James and John called together the seven disciples with Nicodemus and Joseph, and many others of the seventy-two, and they ate with Jesus. The third day Jesus Gospel of barnabas carbon dating "Go to the Mount of Olives with my mother, for there I will ascend again to heaven, and you will see who shall bear me up. And as they all stood in prayer, at midday Jesus came with a great multitude of angels who were praising God: and the splendour of his face made them greatly afraid and they fell with their faces to the ground.
But Jesus lifted them up, comforting them, and saying: "Do not be afraid, I am your master. I said to you that God has granted to me to live almost to the end of the world. Truly I say to you, I did not die; it was Judas the traitor. Beware, for Satan will make every effort to deceive you. Be my witnesses in Israel, and throughout the world, of all things that you have heard and seen. Rest in God who created you and me.
For me, at first errors proves this is not forgery, beacuse Gospel of barnabas carbon dating muslim would ever say muhammed is messiah and jesus not messiah, or other stuff which contradict qur'an. Of course, I also believe that the Gospel of Barnabas is not a forgery, Muslims could not wrote it, since it contains some contradictions, and Muslims would not contradict the Quran. If Barnabas quote it from his memory, then it is possible that he could have make some errors, it is natural.
This Gospel has intrigued me since I've discovered some very interesting parallel allusion to the text of Isaiah, and I think it can resolves some puzzled passages relating to the old testament prophecies!
Pyyntöäsi ei voi käsitellä
The Gospel of Barnabas should be systematically studied especially by Muslims. Take care, and salam Ahmed Poland, Warsaw. Quote from: Idris on February 16,AM. Brother dawud as u mentioned some contridictions, i mentioned in a different theead with answers to the supposed contridictions in bible of barnabas. Brother Dawud i used to think these were contridictions to, but the article i posted at thread which link i posted below, shows that bible of barnabas doesn't have contridictions in regards to think that it mentions that compare with quran.
Quote from: adilriaz on February 16,PM. Asalam ul laykum brother dawud. Absolutely true. The work was not done by me, it was done some brother named Adeel.
Year old bible confirms that jesus christ was not crucified
I do agree, that no muslim would lie about such a serious claim. When i read his work it did make alot of sense and did look like that he refutted what answering islam claimed. s: [ 1 ] 2 All Go Up. SMF 2.
